Skip to content
Trail & Tarp

Gear category

The Camp Kitchen: Stoves, Coolers and Keeping Food Cold

Two numbers dominate this category, BTU and days of ice, and both are quoted in ways that mislead. Here is what they actually mean.

A camp stove and cooking gear set up outdoors

Start here if…

Buying a first stove? Best camp stoves, then propane vs butane for the fuel decision. Buying a cooler? Best coolers for camping. Already have both and the food keeps going warm? How to keep food cold camping is a technique problem, not a shopping one.

Cooking away from the car? Backpacking stoves sorts the four stove types by what you actually cook. For the rest of the kitchen, see soft coolers and camping mugs.

Cooling food, or cooking it? Budget coolers argues technique over spending, wheeled coolers does the loaded-weight math, and Coleman vs Igloo explains why both publish the same claim. For heat, see camping griddles, dutch ovens, cast iron vs stainless and 12V fridges.

Drinking and cooking on the road? Water bottles comes down to insulation and what the lid does, and stoves for van life and overlanding is judged on closed height and wind, not BTU.

Weighing two options? Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket turns on whether you cook or boil, YETI vs Coleman names the three cases the premium box earns, griddle vs grill follows the food, and coolers for a week is where retention stops being theoretical.

Tired of meltwater? Best ice packs for coolers is decided by freeze point, which most brands never print.

Need something to eat off, not cook in? Best camping mess kits counts by the number of people eating and explains why a cookware set is not the same purchase.

Done with buying ice? Best 12V coolers for camping explains the one spec that decides the whole category — these cool a fixed number of degrees below the air around them rather than holding a set temperature — and does the arithmetic on which days that is safe for food.

Trail & Tarp earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

In this category

What BTU means, and why the headline number misleads

BTU per hour measures how fast a burner delivers heat. The trap is that some manufacturers publish a total across all burners and others publish per burner. Coleman's Classic stove is 20,000 BTU total across two burners, roughly 10,000 each. Camp Chef's Everest 2X is 20,000 BTU per burner. Same headline number, twice the stove.

High output matters in three situations: boiling large volumes, cooking in wind, and cooking in cold. Making eggs for two on a still summer morning, a 10,000 BTU burner is entirely adequate and you will notice nothing. That is why we do not tell everyone to buy the biggest stove.

The fuel question, settled

Propane keeps producing usable vapor pressure well below freezing. Butane stops as it approaches freezing — the canister is not empty, it simply cannot make vapor. Isobutane blends exist to split the difference, which is why nearly every backpacking canister is a blend.

For US camping, availability decides it anyway. The green 16.4 oz propane cylinder is stocked by campground stores, hardware stores and highway gas stations everywhere. Butane cartridges are not. If you have ever run out of fuel on a Saturday evening two hours from anywhere, that fact outweighs everything else.

Coolers, and why day claims are not comparable

There is no standard test for ice retention. Each brand runs its own protocol, so a five-day claim and a seven-day claim were not measured the same way. Coleman publishes “up to 5 days at temperatures as high as 90 F” for the 70-quart Xtreme; Igloo publishes the same for the BMX 52; RTIC publishes “up to 7 days” for its Ultra-Light while explicitly attaching its own cooling tips. YETI publishes no day count at all for the Tundra 45, and instead gives a 2:1 ice ratio: 54 cans with no ice, 28 cans packed with ice.

That last figure is the honest one, and it applies to every cooler. A cooler packed correctly holds about half as much food as its can rating suggests, because the rest is ice.

CoolerCapacityPublished ice claimEmpty weight
Coleman 70 qt Xtreme70 qt / 100 cansup to 5 days at 90 Fnot published
Igloo BMX 5252 qt / 83 cansup to 5 days at 90 F16.4 lb
RTIC 52 QT Ultra-Light76 cans / 51 lb iceup to 7 days with RTIC's tips21 lb
YETI Tundra 4554 cans / 37 lb iceno day count published24.6 lb
All figures as published by the manufacturers.

Technique beats equipment here

More than anywhere else in camping, what you do matters more than what you buy. Pre-chilling the cooler, using block ice rather than cubes, packing two parts ice to one part food, keeping drinks in a separate cooler so the food one stays shut, and leaving the meltwater in — those five habits will outperform a category upgrade on almost any weekend trip.

The kitchen is a workflow

Set it up in a line: cooler, prep surface, stove, wash station, with the stove at the downwind end so smoke blows away from food and dirty water never crosses back over clean surfaces. The two items people forget are a second water container and a light above the work surface, and both cost very little.

None of this gear has been tested by us. The BTU figures, ice claims, weights and dimensions are all published by the manufacturers, cited on each page, and the reasoning on top of them is ours. See how we research.

Questions people actually ask

QHow many BTU do I need in a camp stove?

About 10,000 BTU per burner is adequate for normal camp cooking. 20,000 BTU per burner boils large pots faster and holds temperature better in wind and cold. Check whether a stove's headline figure is per burner or a total across both.

QHow long does ice last in a cooler?

Manufacturers claim up to five days for standard hard coolers and up to seven for thicker rotomolded ones, but there is no standard test, so the claims are not comparable. Pre-chilling, block ice, a 2:1 ice ratio and fewer lid openings matter more than the brand.

QShould I use propane or butane for camping?

Propane, for US camping. It works well below freezing where butane loses canister pressure, and the 16.4 oz cylinders are stocked almost everywhere near a campground. Butane suits warm-weather tabletop stoves.

Read next