Camping questions, answered straight

Five systems: shelter (tent, stakes, mallet), sleep (a pad and a bag per person), kitchen (stove, fuel, cooler, two water containers, basic cookware), light (a lantern plus a headlamp each) and comfort (a chair each). Everything else can be borrowed or improvised on a first trip.

Buy a tent rated for two more sleepers than you have, and check it gives at least 20 square feet of floor per person. Two people want a 4-person tent at 55 to 65 square feet; a family of four wants a 6-person at 85 to 100 square feet.

Only in the sense that six adult sleeping pads fit edge to edge with nothing else inside. CORE Equipment publishes both figures for its own tents: its 9-person is listed as most comfortable for four plus gear, and its 6-person for three plus gear.

Almost always the pad, not the bag. Your body weight crushes the insulation underneath you flat, so the ground draws heat away all night. The fix is a pad with a higher R-value, and R-values add up, so stacking a foam pad under an air pad works.

R 1 to 2 for summer, R 3 to 4 for three-season camping, and R 5 or more for frozen ground. Since 2020 all pads sold in the US are tested to ASTM F3340, so the numbers are comparable between brands.

Usually the ISO limit rating, which is a survival-adjacent figure rather than a comfort one. Kelty publishes ISO comfort 31 F and limit 21 F for its Cosmic Down 20, and Marmot publishes comfort 32.2 F and limit 21.6 F for the Trestles Elite Eco 20. Buy on the comfort number.

Manufacturers claim up to five days for insulated hard coolers and up to seven for thick rotomolded ones, but there is no standard test so the claims are not comparable. Pre-chilling, block ice, a 2:1 ice ratio and fewer lid openings matter more than the brand.

Propane for US camping. It keeps producing pressure well below freezing where butane stops, and the 16.4 oz cylinders are stocked at campground stores, hardware stores and gas stations nationwide.

About 10,000 BTU per burner is adequate for normal camp cooking. Check whether a stove's headline number is per burner or a total: Coleman's Classic is 20,000 BTU total across two burners while Camp Chef's Everest 2X is 20,000 BTU per burner.

Not for occasional camping on grass. Yes on gravel or hard-packed ground, if you pitch often, or to keep mud out of the packed tent. It protects against abrasion; it does not make the tent more waterproof, and cut too large it funnels water underneath you.

We do not publish fixed totals because prices move weekly. The shape is consistent though: shelter and sleep are the two biggest items, the kitchen can start almost free with pans from home, and the gap between budget and mid-range gear is largest in the sleep system.

Tent, sleeping pad, sleeping bag, light, stove, chairs, in that order. The pad comes before the bag because the ground is what makes people cold, and a good pad with a cheap bag beats a good bag on a thin mat.

Car camping, unless you already hike regularly with a loaded pack. It lets you learn to pitch, cook and sleep outdoors with a car twenty feet away, without also managing pack weight, water treatment and navigation.

A real sleeping pad rather than a thin foam mat, a bag that fits rather than an oversized hand-me-down, a hat and dry sleeping socks, and making sure they go to bed already warm rather than after sitting still in the cold.

About three hours before sunset on a first trip. Pitching a tent, inflating pads and setting up a kitchen are all straightforward in daylight and unpleasant by headlamp.

No, and we say so on every roundup. There is no test lab and no gear closet here. Instead we compile published manufacturer specifications, name the standard behind every rating, do arithmetic you can reproduce, and pull live retail prices.

Because everything we assert is checkable. Every product page links to the specification we read, every explainer names the standard it describes, and every pick states a drawback. It is a reproducible method rather than someone's impression of a night outdoors.

Affiliate commission. When you buy through a link here the retailer may pay us a commission at no extra cost to you. Commission never affects which products appear, their order, or what we say about them. Full detail on the affiliate disclosure page.

Prices render from a live data feed with a date stamp. If that data is more than 48 hours old the number disappears and the button reads check price instead. We never type a price into a page, because a typed price is out of date the day after it is written.

No. This site has no customers and no clientele, so any testimonial here would be invented by definition. We publish editorial recommendations based on published specifications, and nothing that pretends to be a customer's words.