Skip to content
Trail & Tarp

Knives & tools

Knife vs Multi-Tool for Camping: Which One Earns Its Pocket Space

A multi-tool does eighteen things adequately. A knife does one thing well and weighs a fifth as much. Which is right depends on whether anything at your campsite has screws in it.

By Sawyer V.Published September 27, 2026Last updated September 27, 2026How we research
A campfire burning down into embers

Trail & Tarp earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

The short answer

The short answer

Backpacking, or if you mostly cut food and cord: take the knife. Car camping with a vehicle, a stove, poles and a family: take the multi-tool, because the pliers are what you will actually reach for. The tiebreaker is whether anything you brought has a screw, a wire or a stuck fitting in it.

Compared on published numbers

Opinel No.08Victorinox HuntsmanLeatherman Wave+
Typefolding knifeSwiss Army knifemulti-tool
Weight1.6 oznot published on the page we read8.5 oz
Blade length3.35 in / 8.5 cmnot published2.9 in / 7.37 cm
Tools11518
Pliersnonoyes
LockVirobloc rotating collarnot publishedlocking tools
Warrantynot publishednot published25 years
Figures as published by Opinel, Victorinox and Leatherman. Blank cells are figures the makers do not publish on the pages we read.

The weight column is the whole argument on one axis: 1.6 oz against 8.5 oz. The Wave+ is more than five times the knife, and on a pack that is a real decision. In a car it is nothing.

What the knife does better

What the multi-tool does better

Pliers, mostly. Everything else on a multi-tool is a bonus; the pliers are the reason to carry one. A stuck tent pole ferrule, a bent stake, a hot pot lid, a broken zipper pull, a stove jet — all of those are plier problems and none of them are knife problems.

Then scissors, which cut tape and dressings far better than any blade, and a driver for the screws in a lantern, a camp chair or a roof rack. The Wave+ publishes outside-accessible blades, meaning you can open the knife without unfolding the tool, which removes the main daily annoyance of the format.

The Victorinox Huntsman sits between the two: 15 tools including scissors and a saw at a weight far closer to a knife, with no pliers. For a lot of campers it is the honest answer to this whole page.

A repair kit beats both for the failures that end trips

Neither tool fixes the things that actually go wrong: a torn tent fly, a punctured pad, a snapped pole, a delaminated boot sole. Those need tape, patches, a pole splint and cord. Carry the small kit in camp gear repair kit essentials and treat the knife or multi-tool as the thing that helps you use it, not as the fix itself.

Steel, and the one maintenance rule

Opinel publishes two options: XC90 carbon or Sandvik 12C27 stainless. Carbon takes a keener edge and rusts if you put it away damp; stainless is more forgiving and slightly harder to sharpen. For camping, where knives get used on wet food and left in a pocket, stainless is the lower-maintenance choice.

The rule either way: dry it before it goes in the bag. The Opinel's beech handle also swells when soaked, which can jam the blade shut until it dries — a known quirk, not a fault.

So which should you buy?

If this is youCarry
Backpacking, counting ouncesthe folding knife
Cutting food, cord and packagingthe folding knife
Car camping with a vehicle and a familythe multi-tool
Anything you own has screws or a stuck fittingthe multi-tool
You want one tool for botha Swiss Army knife with scissors and a saw
First aid is a real considerationwhichever has scissors
Our reading of the published figures and the jobs above.

For most households, the honest setup is a cheap folding knife in the kitchen box and a multi-tool in the car, because they are solving different problems in different places. The full fields are in best camping knives and best multi-tools for camping.

The gear this page points to

Questions people actually ask

QDo I need a knife or a multi-tool for camping?

A knife if you are backpacking or mostly cutting food and cord; a multi-tool if you are car camping with a vehicle, a stove and poles. The deciding question is whether anything you brought has a screw, a wire or a stuck fitting, because those are plier jobs a knife cannot do.

QIs a multi-tool blade as good as a real knife?

No. The Leatherman Wave+ publishes a 2.9 in blade against the Opinel No.08's 3.35 in, and you grip folded pliers instead of a proper handle. It cuts adequately; a dedicated knife cuts better and is far easier to sharpen.

QWhat is the lightest option?

The folding knife by a wide margin. Opinel publishes 1.6 oz for the No.08 against Leatherman's 8.5 oz for the Wave+, more than five times the weight. On a backpacking list that is a real difference; in a car it is irrelevant.

QCarbon or stainless steel for a camping knife?

Stainless for most campers. Opinel offers XC90 carbon, which takes a keener edge but rusts if stored damp, or Sandvik 12C27 stainless, which is more forgiving of wet food and a pocket. Either way, dry the blade before it goes in the bag.

Sources

Every figure on this page comes from a published source. We have not tested this gear, so the numbers are the manufacturer's or the standard body's, not ours. How we research.